constitution · epochs · watch · epoch 3
llm.judgment
ev_2971aeae88e97e1ce603ae9d56bca3be785c21fbdfd749343b662cb48c731c59
kindllm.judgment
epoch3
recorded_at_ms1784497329818
previous_event_sha2566c738e95ae6a922e5d5bd2a5444ba836cb27e9c5c8420c0ae95c62fc41862c50
schema_version2
links
- comparison_id: cmp_db6885d5d2a28dab4866e87c239c36e68221fd648662e5698b76fa2db4b5712a
- attempt_id: att_a428ef426a49d969ccb14d7870d61b138b068e642de070940e6419423382777d
- judgment_id: jud_7dc741343d7e543c85a31d66aca8fcbf29d1c620689a0fb3888f9a2801ab2bd6
- epoch 3
payload
{
"attempt_id": "att_a428ef426a49d969ccb14d7870d61b138b068e642de070940e6419423382777d",
"comparison_id": "cmp_db6885d5d2a28dab4866e87c239c36e68221fd648662e5698b76fa2db4b5712a",
"explanation": "Commit B implements a substantial, working feature: a background Reddit fetch worker with OAuth token handling, rate-limit/backoff logic, URL mapping, JSON parsing, and integration into app state/routing, backed by unit tests. Commit A is a small, valuable but narrow security fix (HTML sanitization via ammonia) plus a large generated Cargo.lock diff, which is useful but much smaller in scope and lasting design impact than B's core feature implementation.",
"judgment_id": "jud_7dc741343d7e543c85a31d66aca8fcbf29d1c620689a0fb3888f9a2801ab2bd6",
"model_id": "~anthropic/claude-sonnet-latest",
"ratio": "3:1",
"summary": "~anthropic/claude-sonnet-latest: B (3:1)",
"winner": "B"
}