llm.judgment

ev_d21240f5a6a41da53e8ed64b86d7b2936b0563bd2db1d3b4dfa1e2db176a33ba

kindllm.judgment

epoch3

recorded_at_ms1784499100259

previous_event_sha2565609144851cb7cde6dd3dacbe15457965b4e1870f7f557f54d9c0116853fcc64

schema_version2

payload

{
  "attempt_id": "att_d017f377dce13402568ad528613e8593eaf2d86f13a984e3c6150278683ee837",
  "comparison_id": "cmp_74c5a06ff0dc1775499e7bc06b66ee010339feb752dfce5b52f2b920e9180874",
  "explanation": "Side B fixes a genuine reentrant RwLock deadlock in RoomCreate/RoomGrant RPC handlers (dropping guards before nested read().await calls), which is a real correctness bug that could hang the server in production, plus hardens test infra (HTTP timeouts, log-file redirection to avoid pipe deadlocks) and corrects wrong test assertions. Side A is a solid, well-tested feature addition (garden ranking copy button) but is pure new surface area without fixing any existing defect, making B's contribution more consequential despite its terse commit message.",
  "judgment_id": "jud_a80ccee93497ff786798f4a737e4d3499b10ac44550e1af671baef9d05ac107c",
  "model_id": "~anthropic/claude-sonnet-latest",
  "ratio": "6:4",
  "summary": "~anthropic/claude-sonnet-latest: B (6:4)",
  "winner": "B"
}

ev_d21240f5a6a41da53e8ed64b86d7b2936b0563bd2db1d3b4dfa1e2db176a33ba

links

payload