constitution · epochs · watch · epoch 3
llm.judgment
ev_d4a80dcb13b16133723221617f74c17cb9c246f09272f660fa8b20c46eb612e6
kindllm.judgment
epoch3
recorded_at_ms1784492124196
previous_event_sha256fde57db1d1e722f716956f19063418c5235b9632abccbaf83a38f45e3ea13abe
schema_version2
links
- comparison_id: cmp_7a8df722783d5c25ea6eccd114ca5fac0ef934f86dc3367bd077601b0eb651a8
- attempt_id: att_32227c6e745e9896091169a19567f6c35b7da9c9c0e3516d97a9b467207eb7af
- judgment_id: jud_269ce4a4d383da38a4dc3b50f21d8a8ab350b5f2410f78bcf2ef2579b0fee828
- epoch 3
payload
{
"attempt_id": "att_32227c6e745e9896091169a19567f6c35b7da9c9c0e3516d97a9b467207eb7af",
"comparison_id": "cmp_7a8df722783d5c25ea6eccd114ca5fac0ef934f86dc3367bd077601b0eb651a8",
"explanation": "Side A delivers substantial new functionality and infrastructure: it adds a dedicated pairwise voting page, pair-selection logic that prioritizes bridging disconnected ranking components, in-place UI morphing after votes, ID normalization via `ItemId::from_storage`, and accompanying integration/tests. Side B fixes an important operational issue by requiring OAuth when configured, refreshing tokens after 401/403 responses, and improving error handling, but it is a narrower reliability improvement compared with the broader, lasting feature and architectural additions in Side A.",
"judgment_id": "jud_269ce4a4d383da38a4dc3b50f21d8a8ab350b5f2410f78bcf2ef2579b0fee828",
"model_id": "openai/gpt-chat-latest",
"ratio": "5:2",
"summary": "openai/gpt-chat-latest: A (5:2)",
"winner": "A"
}