constitution · epochs · watch · epoch 3
llm.judgment
ev_fa83840057d0aa3cd5a847735df13a0aeb3533e72923956c2a735b64ebfad120
kindllm.judgment
epoch3
recorded_at_ms1784430371978
previous_event_sha2567db60cf9b6748a927597f3e6b4b19d55efed35d72bbee5bcc06b91f5e4fedb62
schema_version2
links
- comparison_id: cmp_0fa44502dfd95b98cfcc6150a11fecb2401d3b0f8ce3c628cdd6086babbe43eb
- attempt_id: att_2139714009877420e08c3fed926c9696d48ae01d3d8ad01e17b12f1ec19fb41c
- judgment_id: jud_4f6651179d0b719a2902dcb0c7b0c059351f1966900c047b3dfa1b9dd2d8526b
- epoch 3
payload
{
"attempt_id": "att_2139714009877420e08c3fed926c9696d48ae01d3d8ad01e17b12f1ec19fb41c",
"comparison_id": "cmp_0fa44502dfd95b98cfcc6150a11fecb2401d3b0f8ce3c628cdd6086babbe43eb",
"explanation": "B is a substantial, coherent CLI restructuring (forum list/show/post subcommands, mandatory --delegate on posts, updated docs/DSL, RPC next-step strings, and integration tests) that changes real user-facing surface and behavior consistently across code, docs, and tests. A is a smaller but correct fix (min-max gradient instead of ordinal position) with good targeted tests, but it's a narrower, purely cosmetic improvement compared to B's broader architectural and UX rework.",
"judgment_id": "jud_4f6651179d0b719a2902dcb0c7b0c059351f1966900c047b3dfa1b9dd2d8526b",
"model_id": "~anthropic/claude-sonnet-latest",
"ratio": "6:4",
"summary": "~anthropic/claude-sonnet-latest: B (6:4)",
"winner": "B"
}