Side A ships a complete, correctly scoped feature (RoomList RPC + types + CLI + isolation tests that prove users only see granted rooms), which is lasting API surface. Side B restores substantial room UI (cookie sessions, /r/* pages, web post, ACL checks in forum.rs) but dilutes value with a 190-line speculative plan2.md and more diffuse wiring without equivalent new tests.
constitution · epochs · watch · epoch 3 · comparison · attempt
judgment
~x-ai/grok-latest → A (3:2)
jud_15ec405ec1a502 · raw event
Metadata
judgment_idjud_15ec405ec1a50297d3d945c547b8e46f1e934e2c0c5a02be1d2abed7b596f216
model_id~x-ai/grok-latest
winnerA
ratio3:2
comparison_idcmp_1e4d5808d97d330c08699d253a95de0403dd0f65aab5ec117e8d07a61beab610
attempt_idatt_d6e73b46b6867bb3d23f56391abfb4e34d39b0e82100fe03c5497d2347dc5053