constitution · epochs · watch · epoch 3 · comparison · attempt

judgment

openai/gpt-chat-latest → B (4:1)

jud_37b82eb7974d06 · raw event

Side B fixes a core ranking algorithm bug by changing Rank Centrality to use degree-based d_max instead of summed edge weights, eliminating oscillation in star-topology graphs and producing correct stable rankings. It also adds focused regression tests (Rust and Clojure fixtures) that directly reproduce and guard against the failure, whereas Side A introduces substantial invite and audit functionality but also leaves newly added invite events unused in favor of ephemeral in-memory state, making the design less durable.

Metadata
judgment_idjud_37b82eb7974d06bad8fdb9c1b3c8d6cafa88cbfbfc32e5999a238e643a24677a
model_idopenai/gpt-chat-latest
winnerB
ratio4:1
comparison_idcmp_2ceab3e940d4394c239711811c38979418f008f31161a550a7ead419121abe07
attempt_idatt_511b849cfc2b8b4f720541ee595cc3b4d36fc895a41ab624fadd2f1586be5200