Side A is a focused, verifiable change: it fixes a real bug (the /-/ external garden index always querying a bogus parent so it looked empty), adds a well-tested GitHub import-card resolver feature with unit and integration tests, and includes matching CSS across themes. Side B is a sprawling 'first pass' refactor (REST endpoints collapsed into one 1300-line RPC dispatcher, thread_id renamed/split into room_id+thread_tag, ThreadCreated→RoomCreated) that touches nearly every file; while it adds real room/capability functionality, its own commit message signals it's unfinished/exploratory, and the renames plus monolithic dispatcher trade clarity for scope in a way the fixed, tested bug/feature in A does not.
constitution · epochs · watch · epoch 3 · comparison · attempt
judgment
~anthropic/claude-sonnet-latest → A (60:40)
jud_494d3b49258009 · raw event
Metadata
judgment_idjud_494d3b4925800935b6b120d267df6d24994547ec840a76b4288927a73f3ae0f7
model_id~anthropic/claude-sonnet-latest
winnerA
ratio60:40
comparison_idcmp_b59b1ad45cb21212ea6dfd6e720c7d4bd94c8cf7d916feecab49bcc81c20e78f
attempt_idatt_9fb1e38de8070c1f44dcf35da480207964d5194383401151cdff3e7f3b41d713