A redesigns core pair selection with lasting ranking-hub behavior: bridge sub-priorities (merge established → attach isolate → isolate pair) and rank-adjacent zip refinement once the pool is connected, backed by targeted unit tests. B is valuable multi-layer input validation (reject 0 and >100 ratios in DSL, UI, and reducer) but is a narrower correctness guard than A’s algorithm change to the main voting loop.
constitution · epochs · watch · epoch 3 · comparison · attempt
judgment
~x-ai/grok-latest → A (3:1)
jud_526e2bad956278 · raw event
Metadata
judgment_idjud_526e2bad956278c59cf69e0f2d97e773b93f09a5c1181a753fb9c90d0c0f73e6
model_id~x-ai/grok-latest
winnerA
ratio3:1
comparison_idcmp_0cd71089ad1ef46e2ffe58f3fa0ba0c159ddd834d5780494b8ad9e74f157b5c0
attempt_idatt_aad3cb875939cd805f0b421943e6a6958d85e8a6ae0ed77734a22a7eed4fec10