constitution · epochs · watch · epoch 3 · comparison · attempt

judgment

openai/gpt-5.2-chat → B (1:5)

jud_548a2c4545f928 · raw event

Side B delivers a substantial UI and correctness improvement: fixes vote compare highlighting, rewrites slider polarity logic, adds winner semantics, updates CSS rendering for center-anchored gradients, adjusts JS behavior, removes obsolete code, and introduces multiple focused tests including an end-to-end ranking invariant. It spans several modules (HTML, CSS, JS) with meaningful behavioral impact. Side A is a small cleanup removing dead code and adjusting a single test expectation. Therefore, Side B contributes significantly more overall value.

Metadata
judgment_idjud_548a2c4545f92859d156d52889d7873555e59e7b002c450c620b78ee2167d57d
model_idopenai/gpt-5.2-chat
winnerB
ratio1:5
comparison_idcmp_736eca2877be1d3222a1835cf3ee9be80818528caaecdee6e647f50ee6f94282
attempt_idatt_adbe6272e08fa93cb2524ab46636b0fac417c335ff49e496d6c685ee2d98a290