constitution · epochs · watch · epoch 3 · comparison · attempt

judgment

openai/gpt-chat-latest → A (5:1)

jud_72379fcc1e8af6 · raw event

Side A implements a coherent new feature with lasting behavior changes: `/vote` gains pool-scoped navigation, optional `pool` query handling, automatic pair selection from a parent's children, UI links to 'vote on children', and propagation of pool context through post-success navigation. Side B mixes many unrelated changes, including a large checked-in design document (`plan2.md`) and broad UI/auth refactoring; while it contains useful work, the patch is diffuse and harder to attribute to a single focused, durable improvement than Side A's end-to-end voting enhancement.

Metadata
judgment_idjud_72379fcc1e8af6b38bfefbed3189b0647b476e7cacab3ba94dc41f1d0d68eb32
model_idopenai/gpt-chat-latest
winnerA
ratio5:1
comparison_idcmp_e07c3c4994519b07530840ceef4e7f654022a9c5f570ef06f51d093ede31257a
attempt_idatt_b6b51a9c479efb57fc5db876ea0393204e20bca6765a70ecb8996e6a9f554090