Side A adds a clean, well-scoped feature (RoomList RPC + CLI subcommand) with a comprehensive integration test proving per-user isolation, and updates the test runner/bb.edn accordingly—clear, self-contained, verifiable value. Side B is a large, messy web-UI wiring commit that includes a stray AI-generated design essay (plan2.md) accidentally committed, mixes cookie-auth, routing, and room-view logic without any tests, and has questionable production hygiene (committing chat transcripts) that undermines its lasting value despite larger scope.
constitution · epochs · watch · epoch 3 · comparison · attempt
judgment
~anthropic/claude-sonnet-latest → A (8:2)
jud_86adb01ec7e2b5 · raw event
Metadata
judgment_idjud_86adb01ec7e2b559ae13fdf972609fd0efa5fd63be7c787e8fb19bb6cd18011a
model_id~anthropic/claude-sonnet-latest
winnerA
ratio8:2
comparison_idcmp_1e4d5808d97d330c08699d253a95de0403dd0f65aab5ec117e8d07a61beab610
attempt_idatt_fa8796392956e66d5053a216cfc86803428346577916be0194f0e34781fd0535