constitution · epochs · watch · epoch 3 · comparison · attempt

judgment

openai/gpt-chat-latest → A (4:1)

jud_9772349a2ff56b · raw event

Side A implements a functional UX improvement: the auth flow now returns HTML fragments instead of redirects, the shared Poem JS can morph a form with non-empty responses for inline success/error handling, and the auth templates are refactored to reuse form rendering while restoring the standard layout. Side B is a broad but largely mechanical DSL syntax migration—updating the parser, documentation, fixtures, and tests to require explanation-first vote syntax—which changes conventions more than it adds enduring capability.

Metadata
judgment_idjud_9772349a2ff56b2929552fb948dc2d007168f0d1ea76d5f67219e53a2caebd1d
model_idopenai/gpt-chat-latest
winnerA
ratio4:1
comparison_idcmp_423e4056444690884569fbf240eaef83bcfab05bcc2fa8bff4c5b3cc0f5dfd28
attempt_idatt_ac256df1c645e7a4ba5ac031282b88bdc3e1ebc9e5919868ff76b38cc45d56ef