constitution · epochs · watch · epoch 3 · comparison · attempt

judgment

openai/gpt-chat-latest → A (5:2)

jud_a442e714a50c9c · raw event

Side A replaces GitHub API-based commit fetching with a deterministic multi-repository Git discovery pipeline, including mirrored repositories, replayable reachability snapshots, patch-ID deduplication, discovery events persisted to the ledger, concurrency/file locking, and extensive real-Git integration and property tests. Side B adds a useful invite system, room audit RPCs, and timeline/UI support, but it also leaves parts incomplete (for example `RoomRevoke` is explicitly unimplemented and invite events are defined but the implementation relies on ephemeral in-memory state), making it a narrower and less foundational contribution.

Metadata
judgment_idjud_a442e714a50c9cbe1a8e99fc745b5693747ccdd08c920f46e0b8efaf040dfb3b
model_idopenai/gpt-chat-latest
winnerA
ratio5:2
comparison_idcmp_19afb45ec30eb5a624ce49d38eded03405c427ce0cfe96ad303f65f6d3fe325a
attempt_idatt_eee60dbaa14d6bde86529e9f3456ab710f10a208c915f587b68ffb665f0a437c