constitution · epochs · watch · epoch 3 · comparison · attempt

judgment

openai/gpt-chat-latest → B (9:1)

jud_dbe2b4c8b8c28a · raw event

Commit B delivers a substantive user-facing fix for vote comparison highlighting and polarity. It corrects ranking highlight behavior across groups, reworks vote history visualization to use consistent slider semantics, adds winner labeling, updates CSS and JavaScript to keep visual feedback aligned with vote direction, removes obsolete code, and introduces multiple targeted tests covering orientation, slider mapping, highlighting, and end-to-end ranking behavior. Commit A is a small maintenance change that removes a redundant dead-code guard in the reducer after validating that zero ratios are already rejected upstream, with corresponding test updates. While useful for code cleanliness and correctness, its scope and impact are much smaller than B's.

Metadata
judgment_idjud_dbe2b4c8b8c28afe76fcc2dbd0b854f3956276d94bfa5138318c380c2ec1f8b2
model_idopenai/gpt-chat-latest
winnerB
ratio9:1
comparison_idcmp_736eca2877be1d3222a1835cf3ee9be80818528caaecdee6e647f50ee6f94282
attempt_idatt_741506c8d0ac838c8b05e8b8085230520d388971955a1bd7bc453e531921759a