constitution · epochs · watch · epoch 3 · comparison · attempt

judgment

openai/gpt-chat-latest → B (9:1)

jud_dd5357f3f9f235 · raw event

Side B replaces GitHub API-based commit discovery with deterministic multi-repository Git mirroring, reachability snapshots, patch-identity deduplication, replayable `GitDiscovery` ledger events, and corresponding integration/stateful tests, substantially strengthening the project's core attribution logic. Side A is a large seed commit, but it includes obvious accidental terminal transcript text embedded in source files (for example `forms.rs` and `ranking.rs` begin with shell prompt output), alongside speculative notes and a large amount of initial code, making it a much less reliable lasting contribution.

Metadata
judgment_idjud_dd5357f3f9f235c8375de4b1b38ca0a4d57e7691b67151ee28e2738ff0fb0611
model_idopenai/gpt-chat-latest
winnerB
ratio9:1
comparison_idcmp_65760d4757784a2aff8383919de02074529aec2ec64c69019173fee716fd97d9
attempt_idatt_358a3c9cbc196f963a304e5e6347d526ff03da03182f5814b1d85f68add8bd89